Two boys, one block, and the one the scouts didn’t pick.
There is a block in south St. Louis — the 5400 block of Elizabeth Avenue — that carries a second street sign. It reads Hall of Fame Place. The neighborhood is called The Hill, Italian since the 1890s, when the immigrants came for the clay works and the brickyards and then stayed.
Two boys grew up on that block, facing each other across the pavement. One was Lawrence Berra, who the neighborhood called Lawdie long before the world called him Yogi. The other was Joe Garagiola, nine months younger, born there in February of 1926.
Both were catchers. Both were sons of Italian immigrants who barely spoke English. Both made the major leagues. Only one of them ended up in Cooperstown, and it was not the one the scouts liked.
That became the joke Garagiola told on himself for the next seventy years — that he wasn’t even the best catcher on his street. He got a lifetime of material out of it. He also had it exactly right, and he never once seemed to mind.
The clay works
Joe’s father worked at Laclede-Christy, a clay pipe plant, like most of the men on The Hill. Long days. A lunch pail. A paycheck stretched across a family and a mortgage, with a little going to the church every week.
Read that again, because it is the whole neighborhood in one sentence. Nobody down there was making pipe because they loved pipe. They were making pipe because a house on Elizabeth Avenue does not pay for itself, and because a man’s job in 1938 was to see that it did.
In 1942 the Cardinals ran a tryout. Branch Rickey had both boys out for it, along with a coal miner’s kid from Germantown named Red Schoendienst. St. Louis offered Garagiola a contract that day — five hundred dollars to sign. They offered Berra half that. Berra, sixteen and too proud to take less than the kid across the street, turned it down. St. Louis lost him. New York found him.
A sixteen-year-old signs a pro contract, and the first thing he does with the money is retire his father’s mortgage. In front of the other men. At lunch.
Garagiola took the Grand Avenue streetcar with that check in his hand and rode it straight to the plant, where his father and the rest of the men from The Hill were just sitting down with their lunch pails. He put the check in his father’s hand. It was enough to pay off the house. He wrote later that neither of them said a word, because neither of them had to.
Nine seasons
He was seventeen at Columbus, still the youngest player in that club’s history. The Army took him in April of 1944 — Jefferson Barracks, then Fort Riley, then the Philippines, where he caught for a service team. Discharged in the spring of 1946, twenty years old, and the Cardinals needed catching badly enough to hand a kid half the job.
He said later he wasn’t ready. He was right. He fought to keep his average over .200 that first summer and the town loved him anyway, because he was theirs. On the fifth of August they held Joe Garagiola Night at Sportsman’s Park and gave him a car. People came out from The Hill who did not follow baseball at all, to stand up for one of their own.
Then October. The 1946 World Series against Boston: six hits in nineteen at-bats over five games, and in Game 4 he went four-for-five and drove in three. Ted Williams, playing the only Series of his life, managed five hits in twenty-five tries across the same games. A twenty-year-old rookie out of the clay works outhit Ted Williams. He was the first rookie catcher to put up a four-hit postseason game, and it stood alone for sixty-four years.
That was the summit, and he reached it at twenty. Nine seasons after that, four clubs, a .257 average, 42 home runs. In 1950 he was hitting .347 on the first of June when he collided with Jackie Robinson and separated his shoulder. It was the best year he ever had at the plate and it ended in the dirt.
The second career
Here is where it turns. A journeyman catcher with a good story and a quick mouth started getting asked to speak at off-season dinners. He was good at it. He was better at it than he had ever been at catching.
KMOX put him on Cardinals radio in 1955. From there: NBC, the Saturday Game of the Week, the Today show, the game shows, a best-seller in 1960 about how funny baseball is. He worked beside Tony Kubek, then beside Vin Scully. In 1991 the Hall of Fame gave him the Ford Frick Award, the highest honor the game hands a broadcaster.
His trick, and he said so himself, was that he called games from the point of view of a man who was never sure he’d get in. Not the star’s seat. The bench’s. He had been the guy hitting .107 in 1948 and getting sent down, and he never pretended otherwise. That is exactly why people trusted him in the booth for thirty years.
What the block taught
There is a version of this story where Garagiola is the cautionary tale — the can’t-miss prospect who missed, living out his life in the shadow of the kid across the street.
That version is wrong, and the man himself never told it that way. In the winters, before either of them was famous, he and Berra ran a Christmas tree lot in the neighborhood. It started out as an off-season job. By the late forties they were doing it to raise money for an orphanage.
He grew up on a block where your job was to take your part and hit it clean, and he took his part in four different rooms — behind the plate, at the microphone, at a thousand banquets, and later at the fundraising tables for ballplayers the game had forgotten. In 2014 they gave him the Buck O’Neil Lifetime Achievement Award for the second half of his life. He died in Arizona in 2016, ninety years old.
He wasn’t the best catcher on his street. He knew it before anybody had to tell him, and he built a whole life out of knowing it.
That’s not a consolation prize. That’s a standard.
— The Xaminer